Editorial: NY Times, shame on you

The New York Times ran a piece by Phil Taylor of Greenwire (look up Greenwire, it is an “energy and environment” publication).

I took the time to submit an Editorial, but am not taking the time for the submission to be rejected.

There are several other areas of the piece I find disturbing besides what I address in the below submission, but there is only so much time in the day.

Link to the Times piece: http://www.nytimes.com/gwire/2011/09/20/20greenwire-interiors-new-wild-horse-chief-confronts-growi-35228.html

I urge you all to create your own submission to the Times.

I am crafting doc’s and editing and back on the road…

I always hate to ask… but I do need your help to stay out here and continue the work.

http://WildHorseEducation.org and legal here: http://wildhorsefreedom.org


Guilfoyle, is this ok?

Dear Editor,

While applauding the Times for having covered the issue of Wild Horses and Burros on public land, the journalistic standard of the piece “Interior’s New Wild Horse Chief Confronts…” by Phil Taylor lacks authoritative bases.

Federal law does not “force” the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to “cull” horses. The law instead requires them to manage according to a “multiple use” mandate and to “protect” wild horses as “living symbols of the pioneer spirit of the West.” “Removal” of horses is only one of many tools in the BLM’s toolbox although by choice, it is the only one utilized thus far in the forty-year history of the mandate.

The “advocate community” is rightly concerned that wild herds are not managed under “multiple use,” but are managed at a non viable standard in an inhumane fashion. If an extraction company was forced to operate at the current capacity that our National Treasures are being managed, they would be forced out of business. Genetic bankruptcy is more than a concern, it is a stark reality that would ultimately lead to the extinction of wild horses in the West.

There is no “over population.” There is instead, competition for resources on public land.

If you give away a resource the horses rely on to an entity that operates in a subsidized fashion on public land, you have an “over population” of horses according to the agency. You have also created another avenue for public wealth to go into private pockets on the back of an already over burdened American tax payer.

The agency manages more public land than any other, approximately 262 million acres. All of that land is open to “multiple use,” two-thirds of it open to livestock grazing and a mere 10 percent is currently legal land for wild horse herds. Within that 10 percent, horses are often provided less than 2 percent of available resources.

Fences create artificial migration routes. Water sources are fenced off and roads are being widened for the high speed heavy truck traffic to accommodate expanding extractive interests. These extractive interests compete for water in arid western states. Their thirst for the liquid is rising at an alarming rate.

This agency determined that an “Appropriate Management Level” (AML) of horses for one Herd Management Area was sufficient at three animals. Why did they leave three? The BLM did not want their statistics to show another area “zeroed out” of wild horses.

Joan Guilfoyle is now sitting atop an agency guilty of severe fiscal mismanagement rooted in historic prejudice where private interests can profit. Its failed policy is running full steam toward disastrous consequence to the health of public land. Wild Horses are its chosen scapegoats. It is more than tragic that yet another bureaucrat who parrots the old regime has taken the helm.

Guilfoyle, claiming to have been at the Triple B roundup, states,

“It might be the one in a thousand that rears up against the corral and bumps up against the gate, and people go, ‘Oh my gosh, it got hurt,'” she said. “But that’s one out of thousand that came through more or less agreeably. Part of it, I think, is perception and understanding of what’s happening.”

First death at Triple B

I personally attended more roundups than any government personnel or public observer in the last eighteen months. I documented horrific incompetence and lack of the most basic of humane treatment. That documentation includes a nonstop testimony to numerous daily offensive actions. Triple B is no exception. Taylor, who accepted her words as Gospel, fell down on the job when not seeking where the truth lies.

Mr. Taylor cites one lawsuit that could not halt the roundup. Yet, he fails to cite the suit that succeeded in proving that the Agency is guilty of inhumane treatment. A temporary restraining order (TRO) was issued late last month by the Honorable Howard D. McKibben, a Nevada federal judge (Case 3:11-cv-608). His Honor expressed stern disapproval not only toward the conduct of the helicopter pilot who actually struck an exhausted horse, but toward the BLM’s justification process that “blames the horse” for such incidents The suit remains active in federal court. Meanwhile, Guilfoyle’s agency has yet to address Judge McKibben’s decision. Incredibly, the BLM refuses thus far to even recognize Judge McKibben’s remarks of his being “troubled” by the BLM’s conduct, nor has Guilfoyle’s agency issued parameters for pilot conduct in the wake of the judge’s ruling.

The press has yet to “do their job” and hold the government accountable as our forefathers intended they do when they wrote the Constitution. Taylor’s piece is evidence of spineless reporting where he fails to address press access issues in his warm “welcome aboard” message to Guilfoyle.

As camera lenses and observers catch atrocities, Guilfoyle’s agency closes its doors to observers instead of implementing corrective action. The BLM blames advocates for “not understanding” what they must do. Or, they”blame the horse” for “necessary” abusive treatment.

Two respected organizations, The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press and the National Press Photographers Association, filed a brief in a pending Ninth Circuit appeal (Case 11-16088) over their concern for the Agency’s denigration of constitutional First Amendment “freedom of speech” and “freedom of the press” notions. The case addresses the repeated content control accomplished to minimize “bad press,” when Guilfoyle’s agency systematically excludes the press and public from viewing its horrific handling of wild horses captured from public lands. Remove the press and there is no problem.

It is more than a “shame on you” I send to Phil Taylor for failing to address either of these cases in his article. Mr. Taylor instead, chose the “easy way out,” avoiding the tough and gritty method real journalists employ when ferreting out the truth of their chosen topic. Taylor’s piece legitimizes an agency that is no friend either to America’s wild horse or to the true journalist.

Laura Leigh

Founder, Wild Horse Education

Vice President, Wild Horse Freedom Federation

Plaintiff in the above mentioned Federal lawsuits

Terrified foal forced through the jute after his band was shattered and he was chased with only his mom into the trap, colliding with wings, Triple B


13 thoughts on “Editorial: NY Times, shame on you

  1. Mar Wargo says:

    I know you are working on a report on Triple B and I I am sure you will address the ‘numbers’ of horses lost/died/euthanized. I keep seeing some huge figures on foals from people I don’t know. Wonder where the numbers are coming from.

    • Laura Leigh says:

      There are so far 12 “gather related” deaths reported from Triple B, total.
      They included the little ones BLM claims had “anomalies” in tendons, etc. (during actual foaling season), the little one that maimed herself so badly on the barbed wire BLM failed to remove from the trap area that she had to be killed… etc.

      I am filing doc’s on Barren Valley… those images will be made public as soon as they are filed.

  2. Naomi Gaitan says:

    Oh, Laura, this world is a frightening place. This earth is becoming a battleground for a war of compassion. Humans & animals are suffering beyond belief every moment of the day. It is a hard purpose the Lord has put upon you but He knows you are capable & strong enough to do whatever it takes to see this through. You ask whenever you need help & I’m sure no one will fault you for needing to give all your time & efforts to what you are working on right now. I’m on the commenting, calling, emailing, & networking like a mad woman. You give us all a fantastic surplus of ammonition to use in our efforts to help. THANK YOU & GOD BLESS & KEEP YOU!

  3. Mar Wargo says:

    Thanks, the 12 are the ones I have seen from BLM, also. There is a comment at RT’s that was extreme; 14 foals at Triple D… and I hope this is either corrected or explained.

  4. Linda Horn says:

    Right on point again, Laura! Where the heck has “investigative journalism” gone? This guy was lazy, pure and simple! I don’t see any place to comment. I that normal for the Times? If so, do we have to sent an email? There are bound to be pickups. Maybe we can email this guy and cut-and-paste to them.

  5. Barbara Warner says:

    Terrific rebuttal, Laura.
    Here is Phil Taylor’s Email address also . ptaylor@eenews.net
    His article was completely biased and he should be fired.
    Also see http://www.wildhorsepreservation.org to comment on the NAS committee that is one-sided too.

  6. Paula Denmon says:

    Beautifully & truthfully written. I will send something to them. But it will pale by comparison. I will try to find piece on web & send rebuttal comment. Tonight. Also beg for money. And ck my account to see if something can be spared. Also. Everyone say prayer that my client & IRS reach agreement so that he can buy his Ranch for his Andalusians. And I’ll have funds to help Laura. And fight against slaughter, and adopt mustang. Ok Nuff selfish stuff for me.

  7. Marge Mullen says:

    I have read so many of these biased articles from jounalists who no squat about what the hell is going on.

    I do not hesitate to let them know what I think of them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s